AI Scribe ROI for Podiatry: The 5-Year Annualized Return, Worked Out

A podiatrist on DrChrono asked us a fair question: over five years, what does an AI scribe actually return? Here is the math, with every assumption on the table, the published evidence behind each number, and a calculator so you can replace our numbers with yours.

By the MediAttune.AI team · Published September 22, 2026 · 14 minute read

A physician reads a printed report at a desk beside an illustrative ROI chart for a fictional practice
Imagine the quarterly report where the line finally bends upward: charts closed before you leave the office, evenings back, and the numbers on the page are your own. The pictured report is imagined. The math below shows what yours might really look like.

The short answer

  • Five years of cost for one podiatrist is about $10,700 in our example: a $150-a-month subscription rising 5% a year, plus a few hours of setup.
  • Using the average time savings from the largest multi-site study so far (about 16 minutes per full clinic day), the saved hours are worth about $40,000 over five years at $150 an hour. That is a 275% five-year ROI, or about 30% a year annualized.
  • Counting only money that reaches the bank, from extra visits and fewer denied claims to rework, the same scenario returns about $14,000. That is a 31% five-year ROI, or about 6% a year annualized, and break-even takes around nine months, not weeks.
  • The spread between studies is enormous. Results range from 18 seconds saved per appointment to more than five minutes. Your own before-and-after timing matters more than any headline figure, including ours.
  • DrChrono now has its own built-in scribe, EverHealth Scribe, sold as an add-on or bundled in its top plan. Get that quote before comparing standalone tools.

Most return-on-investment pitches for ambient scribes follow one script. Take a large minutes-saved figure, multiply it by a busy schedule, price the result at a physician's hourly rate, and compare it with a monthly fee. The answer always comes out at thousands of percent. The arithmetic isn't wrong. The inputs are the problem, and so is the quiet assumption that saved minutes turn into dollars on their own.

This guide does the calculation the slower way. We start with what "annualized ROI" should mean for a subscription, then gather the published evidence on time savings, price the real costs for a DrChrono podiatry practice, and run three scenarios over five years. At the end there is a calculator, and a 90-day plan to measure your own number before you commit to a multi-year contract.

What "5-year annualized ROI" means for a subscription

ROI is simple: what you got back, minus what you spent, divided by what you spent. Over five years, that gives you a cumulative five-year ROI.

"Annualized" ROI is where people talk past each other. The standard formula comes from investing, where you put money in once and let it grow:

Annualized ROI = (total returned ÷ total spent)1/5 − 1

That formula treats five years of returns as if they had compounded on a single upfront payment. A scribe doesn't work that way. You pay a little every month and get a little back every month. So we report two numbers throughout this article:

  • Annualized ROI (the formula above). This is the figure a financial advisor or practice broker will recognize, so it is the one you asked for.
  • Average yearly ROI. This is each year's return divided by that year's cost, averaged over five years. For a pay-as-you-go tool it is usually the more honest description of what happens to your cash each year.

We also show net present value at a 5% discount rate, which tells you what the five-year stream is worth in today's dollars, and the break-even month, when cumulative returns first cover cumulative costs.

What the published evidence says about time saved

Time saved is the input that decides everything else, and it is the one vendors are most tempted to inflate. Here is what independent and large-scale studies have found as of September 2026.

Scroll sideways to see every column

StudySettingWhat it found
The Permanente Medical Group rollout, the largest to date (summarized in npj Digital Medicine, 2026)Large integrated group, many specialtiesAbout 18 seconds saved per appointment compared with non-users
Five-center study, JAMA, 2026About 1,800 clinicians at five academic medical centers, 2023 to 2025About 16 minutes less documentation time and 13 fewer minutes in the record per 8 hours of patient care. No significant change in after-hours EHR time. Users saw about one extra patient every two weeks.
UCLA randomized trial, NEJM AI, 2025238 physicians in 14 specialties, two commercial tools versus usual careOne tool cut time in notes by 9.5%. The other showed no statistically significant change.
Mass General Brigham (summarized in npj Digital Medicine, 2026)Academic systemMedian total EHR time down 5.6 minutes per appointment, with the biggest gains in specialty practices and heavy EHR users
Intermountain Health matched cohort (same summary)Integrated systemNo statistically significant productivity gain
EverHealth Scribe launch release, 2026 (vendor-reported)DrChrono practices, data from its AI partnerUsers report about 8 minutes saved per visit. This is the vendor's own figure and hasn't been independently studied.

Two things stand out. First, the independent numbers are much smaller than the marketing numbers. The research you may have seen quoted elsewhere often assumes 3 to 4.5 minutes saved on every note, which is above what most controlled or large-scale studies have measured on average. Second, averages hide a wide spread between clinicians. The same tool can save one doctor very little and another doctor a lot, depending on how they chart today and how fully they change their habits.

There is one result that holds up more consistently than the time savings: how clinicians feel. A 2025 multi-site study in JAMA Network Open found burnout fell from 51.9% to 38.8% among 263 outpatient clinicians after 30 days of use. That's real value. It just doesn't appear on a balance sheet, so we keep it out of the dollar figures and come back to it at the end.

Why podiatry may differ. None of these studies isolated podiatry. Podiatry visits tend to be short, frequent, and procedure-heavy, and much of the required documentation is structured: exam findings, nail counts, modifiers. A tool that drafts a narrative well may help less with the parts of your note that are really checklists. That argues for measuring your own results rather than borrowing anyone's average.

What it costs a DrChrono podiatry practice

Option 1: EverHealth Scribe, built into DrChrono

DrChrono's parent company launched EverHealth Scribe in March 2026, after a beta that ran from February. It listens during the visit, drafts a structured note inside DrChrono for your review, and was testing ICD-10 code suggestions at launch. According to third-party pricing reviews, it's a paid add-on on the Foundation and Growth plans and included in the Premium plan. DrChrono doesn't publish prices for any tier, so the only way to get the real figure is a sales quote.

The advantage of the built-in option is obvious: no copying and pasting, and one vendor relationship. The trade-off is negotiating leverage. If the scribe is bundled into a higher tier, you are really comparing the price difference between tiers, and some DrChrono users on review sites report yearly increases of 10 to 15%. Ask for the five-year price in writing.

Option 2: A standalone scribe, pasted into DrChrono

Standalone tools work with any EHR by producing a note you paste into your chart. Published self-serve prices in 2026 run from about $39 a month for a capped plan to about $150 a month for full use. Freed lists plans at $39, $79 and $104 to $119 a month. Heidi's main paid plan rose to $150 a month, billed annually, in February 2026. Before you sign, confirm that a business associate agreement is included on the plan you're buying, and how long audio and transcripts are kept. We cover those questions in our guide to copy-paste and HIPAA.

The costs people leave out

  • Setup time. A few hours for you to set up templates and learn to narrate your exam, and a few hours for your medical assistant to adjust intake. We price this at about $720.
  • Price increases. We assume the subscription rises 5% a year. Adjust this if your quote locks the price.
  • Review time. You still read and correct every draft. The study figures above are already net of review time, so we don't subtract it twice.
  • Your fee schedule. The 2026 Medicare conversion factor for most physicians is $33.40, and it includes a 2.5% bump that Congress passed for 2026 only. A separate 2.5% "efficiency adjustment" cut work values for most non-time-based services, which includes many procedure codes. We hold visit value flat over five years rather than assume raises.

The five-year model, per podiatrist

These inputs are illustrative. They describe one podiatrist, not any particular practice, and every one of them can be changed in the calculator below.

Scroll sideways to see every column

InputValueWhy
Clinic days per year200Four clinic days a week, 50 weeks
Visits per clinic day25Only used to convert the per-visit study result
Value of an hour of your time$150A common benchmark. Use your own.
Net collected per added visit$100Use your practice's actual average
Denial rework cost per claim$25.20MGMA's average for a practice to rework one denied claim
Subscription$150/monthTop of the self-serve range, rising 5% a year
One-time setup$720About 4 physician hours plus 4 staff hours

Five-year cost comes to $10,666: $2,520 in year one, then $1,890, $1,984, $2,084 and $2,188.

Three scenarios

  • Low. The Permanente result: 18 seconds a visit, or 7.5 minutes a day. That isn't enough time to add a visit, so there is no cash return.
  • Middle. The 2026 five-center JAMA result: 16 minutes a day, and one extra visit every two weeks (25 a year). We also assume one fewer denied claim to rework each month.
  • High. 45 minutes a day, which is above any published average but in line with what heavy EHR users sometimes report. We assume you turn that into one extra visit per clinic day and avoid three denied claims a month.

Scroll sideways to see every column

ScenarioHours saved / year5-yr return5-yr net5-yr ROIAnnualizedAvg yearly ROIBreak-even
Low, time value25$18,750+$8,08476%11.9%77%Month 5
Low, cash only25$0−$10,666−100%n/a−100%Never
Middle, time value53$40,000+$29,334275%30.3%279%Month 2
Middle, cash only53$14,012+$3,34631%5.6%32%Month 9
High, time value150$112,500+$101,834955%60.2%965%Month 1
High, cash only150$104,536+$93,870880%57.9%890%Month 1

Net present value at a 5% discount rate for the middle scenario is about $25,400 counting time value and about $2,900 counting cash only.

Cumulative five-year net return, middle scenario Two lines over 60 months. Counting the value of hours saved, the cumulative net reaches about $29,334 by year five and crosses zero in month 2. Counting only cash from extra visits and avoided denial rework, it reaches about $3,346 and crosses zero in month 9. −$5,000$0$5,000$10,000$15,000$20,000$25,000$30,000StartYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5 Time value: +$29,334 Cash only: +$3,346
Middle scenario, cumulative net over five years. The solid line values every saved hour at $150. The dashed line counts only cash from extra visits and avoided denial rework. Both start at −$720 for setup.

How to read this

The gap between the two lines is the whole story. At the average published time savings, a scribe is clearly worth it if you value your evenings, and only modestly profitable if you need it to pay for itself in cash. Time value is not income. It becomes income only when you fill the time with visits, or when it replaces a cost you're already paying, such as an in-person scribe, transcription service, or staff overtime spent chasing charts.

The high scenario looks spectacular because it assumes both a large time saving and that you turn it into one more patient every clinic day. That requires demand for the slot, a schedule that can absorb it, and staff who can room the extra patient. If those aren't true for your practice, the high row doesn't apply to you however much time the tool saves.

When does it actually break even?

Conceptual chart showing a small initial investment, a break-even point shortly after month zero, and a rising return over seven months
The shape most vendors show: a small upfront cost, then a quick climb. It's a concept, not a measurement. In our worked numbers, this shape only fits the high scenario, or the middle scenario if you count time value.

"Pays for itself in the first month" is the standard claim, and the chart above is the standard picture. It holds in one situation: when you count time value and the tool saves a meaningful amount of time. On a cash basis at the average published savings, break-even in our model lands around month nine. At the low end it never comes.

None of that makes a scribe a bad purchase. It makes a long contract a bad first step. The monthly cost is small enough that the sensible move is a short trial with honest measurement, followed by a longer commitment only if your own numbers hold up.

The podiatry-specific lever: denials and routine foot care

For most specialties, denial savings are a minor line in a scribe ROI model. For podiatry they could matter more, because so much Medicare revenue depends on documentation that payers check line by line.

Routine foot care, including nail debridement (11720, 11721), trimming of dystrophic nails (G0127) and paring of corns and calluses, is excluded from Medicare unless an exception applies. The most common exception is a qualifying systemic condition documented with class findings, reported with a modifier:

  • Q7: one Class A finding
  • Q8: two Class B findings
  • Q9: one Class B finding and two Class C findings

A modifier on the claim that the note doesn't support is a common reason for denial. For mycotic nails without a qualifying systemic condition, the rules are different: the fungal nail diagnosis is reported first, with a second diagnosis for the patient's symptom, such as pain or secondary infection. The CMS billing article for this LCD also expects the note to show that definitive antifungal treatment options were reviewed with the patient at the initial visit. Check your own Medicare contractor's version of the LCD, since details vary.

Here is how a scribe can help, and where it can't:

  • It can only capture what you say out loud. If you palpate an absent dorsalis pedis pulse and don't say so, the draft won't include it. Podiatrists who narrate their vascular and neurological exam get more out of these tools than those who examine silently.
  • It shouldn't pick your modifier. Treat any suggested code as a draft. Before you sign, check that the class findings in the note add up to the modifier on the claim.
  • No study has yet shown fewer denials. The vendor figure of 32% more same-day claim submissions for EverHealth Scribe is about speed, not accuracy. That's why our model gives denial savings only a small line: one to three avoided reworks a month at MGMA's $25.20. A formal appeal, which MGMA cites at about $118 per claim, would make that line bigger.

For more detail, see our guides on podiatry insurance appeal mistakes and documenting mixed-etiology foot complications.

Run your own five-year numbers

Change any input. The results update as you type. Nothing you enter leaves your browser.

Five-year AI scribe ROI calculator

Five-year cost–
Five-year cash return–
Cash ROI: 5-year / annualized–
Cash break-even–
Five-year time value–
Time ROI: 5-year / annualized–

A 90-day plan to find your real number

Before you sign anything longer than a quarter, measure. It takes less effort than it sounds.

  1. Weeks 1 and 2, before the trial. Record three numbers on ordinary clinic days: how many charts are still open at the end of the day, how long after-hours charting takes, and how long 10 typical notes take from the end of the visit to signing. A phone stopwatch is enough.
  2. Weeks 3 and 4, learning. Start the tool. Practise narrating your exam findings out loud: pulses, sensation, skin, nails. Expect to be slower at first.
  3. Weeks 5 to 10, measuring. Repeat the same three measurements on similar clinic days. Track denials on routine foot care separately.
  4. Weeks 11 and 12, deciding. Put your measured minutes into the calculator. If your cash ROI is negative but your evenings are clearly better, that's a legitimate reason to keep paying. Just make the decision knowingly.

For habits that cancel out the savings, see three AI scribe mistakes to stop now. If you want to try tools without a card, start with free AI medical scribes you can try without a credit card.

Where MediAttune fits, honestly

We make a note-drafting tool, so you should know where it stands. MediAttune's scribe works only with Office Ally today. It does not connect to DrChrono. For a DrChrono practice, the realistic scribe choices are EverHealth Scribe or a standalone tool you paste from, and this article's math applies to both.

What does work with DrChrono, and with any other EHR, is our appeal and prior-authorization letter tool. For a podiatry practice where a denied debridement or a documentation dispute can mean a formal appeal, that's the part of our product most likely to be useful to you now.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 5-year ROI of an AI scribe for a podiatry practice?

It depends on how much time the tool saves you and what you do with it. In our middle scenario, five years of cost is about $10,700. Valued at $150 an hour, the saved time is worth about $40,000, a 275% five-year ROI. Counting only cash from extra visits and avoided denial rework, the return is about $14,000, a 31% five-year ROI.

What is the annualized ROI over five years?

Using the standard annualized formula, the middle scenario comes to about 30% a year counting time value and about 6% a year counting cash only. Because a subscription is paid as you go, the average of each year's own ROI is often more meaningful: about 279% a year for time value and about 32% for cash.

How much time does an AI scribe really save?

Published results range from about 18 seconds per appointment at The Permanente Medical Group to a median of 5.6 minutes of EHR time per appointment at Mass General Brigham. The largest multi-site study, published in JAMA in 2026, found about 16 minutes saved per 8 hours of patient care. Intermountain Health found no significant productivity gain.

Does DrChrono have a built-in AI scribe?

Yes. EverHealth Scribe launched inside DrChrono in March 2026. Third-party reviews describe it as a paid add-on on the Foundation and Growth plans and included in Premium. Pricing is by quote only.

Can an AI scribe reduce podiatry claim denials?

Possibly, but it hasn't been shown yet. For Medicare routine foot care, payment depends on class findings in the note that support the Q7, Q8 or Q9 modifier. A scribe records only what you say aloud, so narrate your exam and check the modifier against the note before you sign.

Sources

  1. Ohde JW, Thompson A, Liu Z, et al. Barriers and opportunities of scaling ambient AI scribes for clinical documentation across diverse healthcare settings. npj Digital Medicine 9, 369 (2026). Source for the Permanente, Mass General Brigham and Intermountain results.
  2. Five-center study of ambient AI scribe use, JAMA, 2026, as reported by STAT, April 1, 2026.
  3. Ambient AI Scribes in Clinical Practice: A Randomized Trial. NEJM AI 2025;2(12). doi:10.1056/AIoa2501000.
  4. Olson et al. Ambient AI use and clinician burnout across six US health systems. JAMA Network Open, 2025.
  5. EverCommerce. DrChrono Expands AI Capabilities with Launch of EverHealth Scribe, March 10, 2026. Vendor-reported figures.
  6. DrChrono. Release notes, January 28, 2026 (EverHealth Scribe beta).
  7. Pabau. DrChrono pricing (2026). Third-party review of plan tiers and add-ons.
  8. Merits Research. What one denial costs a small practice. Summarizes MGMA's $25.20 rework figure and the $118 formal appeal figure.
  9. CMS. Billing and Coding: Routine Foot Care and Debridement of Nails (A57759).
  10. Minnesota Medical Association. CMS releases final rule for 2026 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule.
  11. Vero. Heidi Health review 2026 and Plaud, Heidi AI vs Freed AI, for published subscription prices.

This article is general information for practice planning. It isn't financial, legal or billing advice. Prices and coverage rules change, so confirm current figures with vendors and your Medicare contractor.

Start with the free half

Your first 10 appeal and prior-authorization letters written for you — any EHR, including DrChrono, no subscription, nothing to install. Plus early access to the Office Ally scribe.

Get early access + 10 free appeal letters